How to Secure Your Fair Share When You’re Being Underpaid At Work

Have you ever completed a project, poured your heart and expertise into a task, only to be met with a compensation that feels…off? Like a discordant note in a well-rehearsed symphony?

This feeling of being underpaid is a common experience in the professional world. It can be a source of frustration and demotivation, leaving you wondering if your skills and contributions are truly valued.

The good news is, you don’t have to accept this financial undertone. By taking proactive steps, you can determine your market worth, build a compelling case for a raise, and approach your employer with confidence. 

I. Are You Underpaid? Understanding Your Market Value

Feeling undervalued at work is a common concern. But before initiating a conversation about compensation, it’s crucial to assess your market worth and confirm if a pay gap truly exists. Here’s a two-pronged approach to determine your standing:

A. Internal Research: Unveiling the Company Landscape

While some companies offer transparent salary structures, many don’t. However, there are still ways to gather internal insights:

  • Internal Job Postings: Scrutinize job postings for similar positions within your company. Pay attention to the advertised salary ranges – this can provide a ballpark figure for your role and experience level.
  • Anonymous Salary Surveys: Certain companies conduct anonymous employee surveys that include salary information. If your company offers such surveys, participate actively to gain valuable data on internal compensation structures.
  • Confidential Conversations (with Caution): This approach requires discretion. If you have a trusted colleague in a similar position (not a direct competitor) or someone with long experience in the company, consider having a confidential conversation about their salary range or previous salaries for this role. Keep in mind that this information should only be used as a reference point, and external research is still necessary for a more comprehensive picture.

B. External Research: Benchmarking Your Worth in the Market

The internet provides a wealth of resources to compare your compensation with industry standards. Here are some key tools:

  • Salary Comparison Websites: Utilize reputable online salary calculators like Salary.com (https://www.salary.com/) or Glassdoor (https://www.glassdoor.com/Salaries/index.htm) to compare your position, location, and experience with national and regional averages. These websites allow you to refine your search by company size and industry for a more precise comparison.
  • Industry Publications: Industry-specific publications and reports often include salary benchmark data. Explore relevant trade journals or research reports from reputable organizations to understand typical compensation packages for your profession.

Remember:

  • Focus on Data-Driven Evidence: While internal conversations can be helpful, prioritize data from salary comparison tools and industry reports for a more objective picture.
  • Consider Location: Cost of living varies significantly across regions. Factor in your geographic location when evaluating salary data.

By conducting thorough research through both internal and external channels, you’ll gain a clear understanding of your market worth and be able to confirm if a salary gap exists.  This knowledge empowers you to approach your employer with confidence and advocate for fair compensation.

How-to-Secure-Your-Fair-Share-When-You-are-Being-Underpaid-At-Work-market-value

Also Read: Career Success: 32 Soft Skills Proven to Get You Hired (& Promoted)

II. Preparing for the Raise: Building Confidence and Crafting Your Strategy

Skipping preparation is like entering a game without a plan – the outcome is uncertain, and the odds might not be in your favor. Here’s why preparation is critical and how to build confidence for a successful conversation:

A. Why Preparation is Essential

  • Confidence Booster: By meticulously preparing, you’ll gain a strong understanding of your value and the data to support your case. This knowledge translates to confidence during the negotiation, allowing you to present your arguments persuasively.
  • Strategic Advantage: Preparation allows you to anticipate potential objections from your employer and develop effective counterpoints. You’ll be able to navigate the conversation with a clear strategy, increasing your chances of a successful outcome.
  • Empowerment: The act of preparation itself is empowering. It demonstrates your seriousness about your worth and sends a message that you’re well-informed and ready to advocate for yourself.

B. Building Confidence for the Negotiation

  • Acknowledge Your Achievements: Take time to reflect on your accomplishments and contributions to the company. Document specific examples of projects you led, quantifiable results you achieved, and positive feedback you’ve received. This self-reflection reinforces your value and bolsters your confidence.
  • Practice Positive Self-Talk: Challenge negative self-doubt with affirmations about your skills and experience. Remind yourself that you deserve fair compensation and that negotiating is a standard professional practice.
  • Visualize Success: Spend a few minutes picturing a successful negotiation. Imagine yourself confidently presenting your case and reaching a positive agreement. Visualization can significantly improve your confidence and negotiation mindset.

C. Crafting Your Negotiation Strategy

  • Target Raise: Research your market worth and determine a specific, realistic raise percentage or salary figure to aim for. Aim high but stay grounded in data to avoid setting unrealistic expectations.
  • Alternatives: Consider alternative forms of compensation beyond a base salary increase. This could include bonuses, stock options, additional paid vacation days, or increased professional development opportunities.
  • BATNA (Best Alternative To a Negotiated Agreement): Develop a Plan B in case negotiations are unsuccessful. This might involve seeking a new position, exploring internal opportunities, or re-evaluating your long-term goals with the company. Having a BATNA strengthens your position and prevents desperation during the negotiation.

D. Perfecting Your Delivery:

  • Role-Playing: Practice the conversation with yourself in front of a mirror, a trusted friend, or career counselor.This allows you to refine your communication style, practice your justifications, and anticipate potential questions or objections.
  • Anticipate Counter-Offers: Be prepared for potential counter-offers your employer may present. Consider your responses beforehand and determine your minimum acceptable outcome.

E. Gathering Documentation:

  • Performance Reviews: Compile positive performance reviews and feedback to showcase your accomplishments and value to the company.
  • Industry Data: Organize your salary research data from various sources mentioned earlier (salary comparison websites, industry reports). Having this data readily available strengthens your case during the negotiation.

By following these steps, you’ll transform yourself from an unsure employee to a confident negotiator ready to advocate for your fair share. Remember, preparation is key to securing a successful outcome.

How-to-Secure-Your-Fair-Share-When-You-are-Being-Underpaid-At-Work-preparation

Also Read: How To Speak Up Confidently And Silence Your Shyness

III. Having the Conversation Professionally: Initiating the Discussion and Securing Your Worth

The conversation about compensation can be daunting, but with the right approach, you can transform it into a productive dialogue. Here’s how to initiate the discussion professionally and increase your chances of a successful outcome:

A. Initiating the Conversation: Requesting a Meeting

  • Timing is Key: Choose a strategic time to request a meeting. Ideally, schedule it after a successful project completion, during a performance review cycle, or when the company is experiencing positive financial results. Avoid initiating the conversation during times of budget cuts or company restructuring.
  • Direct and Professional Approach: Send a professional email to your manager requesting a meeting to discuss your compensation. Briefly mention your desire to review your salary in light of your contributions and market value.

Example Email:

Subject: Meeting Request – Compensation Review

Dear [Manager Name],

I hope this email finds you well. I’m writing to request a meeting to discuss my current compensation.  Given my recent accomplishments on [project name] and my ongoing contributions to the team, I believe it’s a good time to review my salary to ensure it aligns with my market value and performance.

Would you be available to meet on [date] or [date] to discuss this further?

Thank you for your time and consideration.

Sincerely,

[Your Name]

B. Having the Conversation Professionally

  • Confidence is Paramount: Maintain a professional and confident demeanor throughout the conversation. Projecting confidence demonstrates your seriousness about your worth and strengthens your position.
  • Focus on Value: Frame the discussion around the value you bring to the company and the positive impact you’ve made. Highlight your accomplishments, quantifiable results, and positive contributions to the team.
  • Data-Driven Evidence: Back up your claims with concrete evidence from your performance reviews, industry data on salary benchmarks, and documentation of your achievements.
  • Negotiate Strategically: Be prepared to negotiate, but also be open to compromise. Consider alternative forms of compensation if a significant raise isn’t immediately feasible.
  • Active Listening: Actively listen to your manager’s perspective and any concerns they might raise. Address their points directly and be open to finding a mutually agreeable solution.

Example Dialogue:

You: Thank you for meeting with me today.  As you know, I’ve consistently exceeded expectations in my role, including [mention specific achievements].  I’ve also been actively researching industry standards for my position and experience level.  Based on my research and contributions, I believe a salary increase of [desired percentage] is fair and competitive.

Manager:  [Responds with their perspective]

You: [Actively listen and address their concerns.  Present data or counter-arguments if necessary]. I understand your point regarding [mention specific concern].  However, considering [mention relevant data or accomplishment], I believe a raise of [adjusted percentage/alternative compensation] is still warranted.

C. Following Up:

  • Thank You Email: After the meeting, send a thank-you email summarizing the key points discussed and any next steps agreed upon. This email creates a clear record of the conversation.

By initiating the conversation professionally, focusing on your value proposition, and negotiating strategically, you significantly increase your chances of securing the compensation you deserve. Remember, confidence and preparation are your most valuable assets in this conversation.

IV. Additional Tips and Considerations: Maximizing Your Negotiation Power

Negotiating a raise can be a complex process, and there are additional factors to consider beyond the core strategies discussed previously. Here are some effective tips to further strengthen your position:

A. Know Your Rights:

  • Labor Laws: Familiarize yourself with local labor laws regarding minimum wage and fair pay practices. Understanding your legal rights empowers you during negotiations. Resources like the Department of Labor website can provide valuable information specific to your location.

B. Be Prepared to Walk Away:

  • Setting Your Minimum Acceptable Outcome: Before initiating the conversation, determine your minimum acceptable raise or alternative compensation package. If the offer falls below your bottom line, be prepared to walk away and explore other opportunities. This shows that you’re serious about it and strengthens your bargaining position.

C. Leverage Your Network:

  • Networking and Job Search: If negotiations are unsuccessful and your value isn’t recognized, consider exploring other avenues. Utilize your professional network to identify potential opportunities or update your resume to pursue new positions that offer better compensation. Sometimes, the best way to secure a raise is to demonstrate you have options.

D. Continuous Learning and Development:

  • Invest in Yourself: Continuously develop your skills and knowledge through professional development courses, certifications, or attending industry conferences. Demonstrating a commitment to growth strengthens your value proposition and makes you a more attractive asset to any employer, increasing your long-term earning potential.

E. Seek Mentorship:

  • Guidance from a Trusted Advisor: Consider seeking guidance from a career counselor, mentor, or a trusted colleague who has successfully negotiated raises. Their insights and support can be invaluable throughout the process.


By following these additional tips, you can approach compensation negotiations with a well-rounded strategy and maximize your chances of securing the pay you deserve. Remember,  your value as an employee goes beyond just your current role.  Investing in yourself, staying informed, and being willing to walk away empowers you to navigate the negotiation process with confidence.